Ask HN2019

What are your favorite books or essays written at least 100 years ago?

237 comments named 137 books. The one named most: Meditations, by 9 people.

Asked on Hacker News, Sep 8, 2019 · Read the thread · How this was made

The 12 named most

  1. Cover of Meditations

    1Meditations

    Marcus Aurelius

    named by 9

  2. Cover of The Count of Monte Cristo

    2The Count of Monte Cristo

    Alexandre Dumas

    named by 8

  3. Cover of Les Misérables

    3Les Misérables

    Victor Hugo

    named by 6

  4. Cover of The Art of War

    4The Art of War

    Sun Tzu

    named by 5

  5. Cover of Anna Karenina

    5Anna Karenina

    Leo Tolstoy

    named by 4

  6. Cover of Candide

    6Candide

    Voltaire

    named by 4

  7. EssaysMichel Montaigne, M. Screech

    7Essays

    Michel Montaigne, M. Screech

    named by 4

  8. Cover of The Brothers Karamazov

    8The Brothers Karamazov

    Fyodor Dostoevsky

    named by 3

  9. Cover of The Prince

    9The Prince

    Niccolò Machiavelli

    named by 3

  10. Cover of Moby Dick

    10Moby Dick

    Herman Melville

    named by 2

  11. Cover of Tao Te Ching

    11Tao Te Ching

    Stephen Mitchell

    named by 2

  12. Cover of The Wealth of Nations

    12The Wealth of Nations

    Adam Smith

    named by 2

What people said

One comment from the thread for each, cut to the part that says why. Amazon links are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. Meditations  Marcus Aurelius, 1559 · named by 9

    “This book is the private diary of the Roman Emperor. He doesn’t say anything about politics or much about other people, just exhorting himself to do better and be better.”

    nindalf, Sep 9, 2019Amazon

  2. The Count of Monte Cristo  Alexandre Dumas, 1844 · named by 8

    “I’m an avid reader and I always laughed at the idea of having a “favorite” book.. until I found mine. I loved the book so much, I resolved to learn French… just so I could someday read it in the original French.”

    ComputerGuru, Sep 9, 2019Amazon

  3. The Art of War  Sun Tzu, 1900 · named by 5

    “It really is profound and is actually more useful than I first thought. Especially "show strength at your weakest, show weakness at your strongest" is something that I've used during negotations and presentations.”

    pimmen, Sep 9, 2019Amazon

  4. Anna Karenina  Leo Tolstoy, 1878 · named by 4

    “It is by far the most interesting book I've read/listened to. I have been moved to tears again and again by this book.”

    markussss, Sep 9, 2019Amazon

  5. Essays  Michel Montaigne, M. Screech · named by 4

    “Michel de Montaigne, his Essays are awesome and touch a wide range of subjects. The 100+ chapters in three books require an investment that will payoff.”

    mkovach, Sep 9, 2019Amazon

  6. The Prince  Niccolò Machiavelli, 1515 · named by 3

    “The Prince, Machiavelli => A little bit cynical but quite realistic about the nature of power in the hands of humans”

    altharaz, Sep 9, 2019Amazon

  7. Atlas Shrugged  Ayn Rand, 1957 · named by 1

    “Atlas Shrugged had the most profound impact on me. Ishmael was a funny, short and enlightening read.”

    lbj, Sep 9, 2019Amazon

Also named by more than one person

14 more books, in the same order.

  1. Cover of On the Shortness of Life

    On the Shortness of Life

    Seneca

    named by 2

    Find on Amazon
  2. Cover of On Liberty

    On Liberty

    John Stuart Mill

    named by 2

    Find on Amazon
  3. Cover of Nicomachean Ethics

    Nicomachean Ethics

    Aristotle

    named by 2

    Find on Amazon
  4. Cover of Letters from a Stoic

    Letters from a Stoic

    Seneca

    named by 2

    Find on Amazon
  5. Cover of Alice in Wonderland

    Alice in Wonderland

    Lewis Carroll

    named by 2

    Find on Amazon
  6. Cover of The mysterious island

    The Mysterious Island

    Jules Verne

    named by 2

    Find on Amazon
  7. Cover of Faust

    Faust

    Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

    named by 2

    Find on Amazon
  8. Cover of The Canterbury Tales

    The Canterbury Tales

    Geoffrey Chaucer, John E. Cunningham

    named by 2

    Find on Amazon
  9. Cover of Around the World in 80 Days

    Around the World in 80 Days

    Jules Verne

    named by 2

    Find on Amazon
  10. On the Electrodynamics of Moving BodiesAlbert Einstein

    On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies

    Albert Einstein

    named by 2

    Find on Amazon
  11. Cover of The Age of Reason

    The Age of Reason

    Thomas Paine

    named by 2

    Find on Amazon
  12. Cover of Second Treatise of Government

    Second Treatise of Government

    John Locke

    named by 2

    Find on Amazon
  13. Cover of Growth of the soil

    Growth of the Soil

    Knut Hamsun

    named by 2

    Find on Amazon
  14. Cover of On the Duty of Civil Disobedience

    On the Duty of Civil Disobedience

    Henry David Thoreau

    named by 2

    Find on Amazon
111 books named once

How this was made

From the site’s data, as of the last data refresh: a book’s count is the number of different people in the thread who named it as an answer, or recommended it in a reply. Books without a page on this site are not counted.

Each quote is a short excerpt of one comment that names the book, picked by a fixed rule: among the 16 books named most, comments that recommend the book, are mostly about it and say why it matters come first. The quotes were then read by hand; where the rule’s pick missed the point, a better excerpt from the same thread replaced it (“…” marks a cut), or the book is shown without one. Follow the date to read the whole comment on Hacker News. All mentions are in the open dataset, mentions.csv.gz.

Keyboard shortcuts

/
Focus search
j / k
Next / previous book
Enter
Open focused book
Esc
Close / go back
g h
Go to Home
g t
Go to Top recommended
g m
Go to Most mentioned
g r
Go to Rising
g f
Go to For You
?
Show this help