Hind SwarajMohandas Karamchand Gandhi

Hind Swaraj

by Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi · first published 2009

6mentions
1recommended by
5HN commenters
2019–2026first – last mentioned

20% recommend60% neutral20% critical

Affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Mentions per year

20 2007: 0 mentions2008: 0 mentions2009: 0 mentions2010: 0 mentions2011: 0 mentions2012: 0 mentions2013: 0 mentions2014: 0 mentions2015: 0 mentions2016: 0 mentions2017: 0 mentions2018: 0 mentions2019: 2 mentions2020: 0 mentions2021: 0 mentions2022: 0 mentions2023: 0 mentions2024: 0 mentions2025: 1 mention2026: 2 mentions200720172026

What Hacker News says

  • rajekas · Jul 12, 2019 · Recommends

    …patronising or racist to say that India needs to follow a different model of development than the western one. In fact, that idea was central to the Gandhian independence struggle - just read the great man's Hind Swaraj! There are many reasons for doing so. For one, we don't have colonies we can screw over - i.e., India's India - while enriching ourselves. Assuming we would want to do that at all. We also don't have…

    on “Apple begins exporting India-made iPhones to European markets” ↗
  • iamshs · Apr 20, 2025 · Mentions

    Good effort. I doubt if real life Gandhi would be like this character though. In Hind Swaraj, Gandhi talks about banning railways and vaccines..

    on “When Gandhi Met Satoshi” ↗
  • paulorlando · Oct 6, 2026 · Mentions

    This piece reminded me, of all things, of Gandhi's essay "Hind Swaraj." He was pretty anti-technological-driven change. He was anti: - Machinery replacing handicraft (skill disappeared and poverty followed) - Labor-saving machines replacing human workers (workers became…

    on “Is mathematics over, or just graduating?” ↗
  • ViktorRay · Oct 6, 2026 · Mentions

    …understand the things I mentioned just now weren’t around in 1908 when Gandhi wrote that essay but who knows what advancements modern AI could bring that we can’t imagine now? https://www.mkgandhi.org/ebks/hind_swaraj.pdf This is a PDF of that Gandhi book. Under the “A Word of Explanation” you find Gandhi saying he would welcome the natural destruction of hospitals and railways.

    on “Is mathematics over, or just graduating?” ↗
  • ViktorRay · Oct 6, 2026 · Critical

    I disagree his arguments are timeless. https://www.mkgandhi.org/ebks/hind_swaraj.pdf I posted more in another comment on this thread but here’s a PDF of his book. Gandhi says in the “A Word of Explanation” section that he would welcome the natural destruction of hospitals. How is…

    on “Is mathematics over, or just graduating?” ↗
  • yesenadam · Aug 14, 2019 · Mentions

    …starved if I am excluded from the Editorship of the Daily Mail," or words to that effect."[0] On reading this, Gandhi "immediately translated it into Gujarati, and on the basis of it he wrote his book Hind Swaraj, his own first formulation of a specifically "Indian" solution to his country’s problems. Thus you might argue, not quite absurdly, that India owed its independence, or at least the manner in which it…

    on “Reading Gandhi Reading” ↗

Keyboard shortcuts

/
Focus search
j / k
Next / previous book
Enter
Open focused book
Esc
Close / go back
g h
Go to Home
g t
Go to Top all-time
g m
Go to Most recommended
g r
Go to Rising
g f
Go to For You
?
Show this help